Episode status: The Traitors: New Blood Episode 5 aired on NBC on October 8, 2026, and is streaming on Peacock. Sherry Kuehl was banished. The episode ended on a murder cliffhanger; Episode 6 revealed the victim was Niyyah Hayes, murdered with the cursed apple.
Episode 5 picks up an unfinished Round Table. At the end of The Traitors: New Blood Episode 4, Jay Vinnedge named Katie Fites as the player he believes is a Traitor. The episode ended before anyone voted. For the full season, see our The Traitors: New Blood season coverage.
Quick Facts
| Detail | Information |
|---|---|
| Series | The Traitors: New Blood |
| Season | 1 (listed on Peacock as The Traitors Season 5) |
| Episode | 5 |
| Listed title | Wake of the Living Dead |
| NBC air date | October 8, 2026 |
| Peacock streaming | October 9, 2026 |
| Runtime | Not confirmed |
| Status | Aired October 8, 2026 |
Where Episode 4 Left Off
Episode 4 ended with the season’s third Round Table just getting started. Jay told the group he would “be concise” this time. He said he had been collecting information over four days and named Katie as his suspected Traitor.
Viewers know Jay’s suspicion is correct. Katie became the third Traitor in Episode 3, joining Joe Vanella and Tomica Adams. The Faithful don’t know that, and Jay’s credibility has taken damage from his unpredictable style earlier in the game.
The accusation also builds on a chain of events. Xavier Scruggs warned other players about Katie before he was murdered as the losing Accomplice. Logan Smith kept raising that warning and was murdered in Episode 4. Michael Foote had started to think Jay’s Katie theory deserved attention.
A second thread is also open. During Episode 4’s Death Parade mission, Alan Cumming told the castle it would attend a funeral for one of the ten players left behind at the gates. Episode 4 did not show who.
Game State After Episode 5
| Category | Status after Episode 5 |
|---|---|
| Players remaining | 16 |
| Traitors | Joe Vanella, Tomica Adams, Katie Fites |
| Faithful | 13 |
| Prize pot | $77,000 |
| Traitors banished so far | 0 |
| Faithful banished so far | Madeline Kostopulos, Arisa Thomas, Sherry Kuehl |
| Murdered so far | Kim Daily, Xavier Scruggs, Logan Smith |
| Active shield | None verified |
| Death Parade shortlist | 10 players, including Joe and Tomica |
| Round Table result | Sherry Kuehl banished 11-5-1; Jay still suspects Katie |
Victor Vollbrechthausen also remains under suspicion after receiving five votes at the Episode 4 banishment.
What Happened in Episode 5
The Round Table: Jay Vinnedge finally laid out his case against Katie Fites, citing information gathered over four days. His argument fell apart under pressure. He pivoted to accusing Kriste Lewis, who shut him down, and Katie turned the table by pointing to Jay’s shifting theories. Kriste pushed back on Jay directly. Abby Lee then built a case against Sherry Kuehl, who had once told her there were three Traitors in the game. When asked who she suspected, Sherry called Jay “a detriment to all of us playing this game.” The room read her sudden outspokenness as suspicious.

The vote: Sherry Kuehl 11, Jay Vinnedge 5, Michael Foote 1. Sherry was banished and revealed she was a Faithful. All six players eliminated so far have been Faithfuls. Jay voted for Sherry but insisted afterward that he still believes Katie is a Traitor. Niyyah Hayes called Jay out for voting Sherry instead of either woman he had accused.
The murder in plain sight: the Traitors had to get one of the seven shortlisted players — Niyyah Hayes, Abby Lee, Morgan Cook, Mark Zgoda, Victor Vollbrechthausen, Kriste Lewis, and Clyde Moser — to catch a poisoned apple. Katie suggested targeting Morgan Cook. Joe Vanella tossed the apple at Morgan, she did not catch it, and Joe ate the apple himself to kill suspicion. Victor Vollbrechthausen noticed Joe clinging to his fruit and later saw Tomica offering apples around the kitchen. The Traitors did land a poisoned apple on someone off camera: Episode 6 revealed the victim was Niyyah Hayes, who caught the apple Joe Vanella tossed during a mock football game.
The wake: the players marched to a graveyard in funeral dress. Nine players were sealed in coffins at the wake. Seven of them were Faithfuls actually at risk of being murdered; Tomica Adams and Joe Vanella, both Traitors, lay in coffins alongside them as cover and were never in danger. Alan Cumming confirmed Tomica Adams, Kriste Lewis, Abby Lee, Morgan Cook, and Victor Vollbrechthausen safe. He began to name the murder victim and the episode cut to credits. The remaining names after the safe reveals are Clyde Moser, Joe Vanella, Mark Zgoda, and Niyyah Hayes — Joe is a Traitor, so safe by definition. The victim was revealed in Episode 6: Niyyah Hayes, murdered with the cursed apple and confirmed as a Faithful. See the full Episode 6 recap.
Where to Watch The Traitors: New Blood Episode 5
Episode 5 aired on NBC on October 8, 2026, and is streaming on Peacock now, listed as The Traitors Season 5. Episode 6 aired October 15; Episode 7 aired October 22; Episode 8 aired October 29.
Frequently Asked Questions
When did The Traitors: New Blood Episode 5 air?
October 8, 2026, on NBC, with Peacock streaming from October 9.
Has Episode 5 aired yet?
Yes. It aired on NBC on October 8, 2026, and is streaming on Peacock.
Who was banished in Episode 5?
Sherry Kuehl, by an 11-5-1 vote. She revealed she was a Faithful.
What happened at the end of Episode 4?
Jay Vinnedge opened the season’s third Round Table by naming Katie Fites as his suspected Traitor. The episode ended before the group voted.
Who are the Traitors going into Episode 5?
Joe Vanella, Tomica Adams and Katie Fites.
Who was murdered in Episode 5?
The episode ended on a cliffhanger before Alan Cumming named the victim. Episode 6 revealed it was Niyyah Hayes, murdered with the cursed apple and confirmed as a Faithful. The remaining names after the safe reveals are Clyde Moser, Joe Vanella, Mark Zgoda, and Niyyah Hayes — Joe is a Traitor, so safe by definition.
Shane Beatty went on to win the season and the full $246,300 prize; see our finale results and our winner predictions.
← Previous Episode
The Traitors: New Blood Episode 4 Recap
Episode Guide
All The Traitors: New Blood episodes
Next Episode →
The Traitors: New Blood Episode 6 Recap (aired October 15)







