Are the Secret Lives of Mormon Wives: Orange County Stars Actually Mormon?

The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives: Orange County cast posing together outdoors in white dresses.
Table of Contents

The Short Answer

Not all of them are. The cast of The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives: Orange County is a mix. Some are practicing members of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints. Some were raised in the faith and left. One was never religious. One is not Mormon at all.

The nine cast members of The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives: Orange County in the official key art

Four of the nine are practicing members: Jen Affleck, McCall DaPron, Madison Bontempo, and Jordan McClanahan, who converted as an adult. Two were raised in the faith and do not practice now: Aspyn Ovard and Salomé Andrea. Ashleigh Pease was raised strictly in the faith and married in the Salt Lake City temple. Avery Woods has said she has never been a religious person. Bobbi Althoff is not Mormon.

The sections below go through each cast member and what they have publicly said about their own faith.

The Cast, One by One

Jen Affleck

Jen Affleck was raised in the Latter-day Saint faith and remains in the church. She is the only cast member crossing over from the original Utah series, and she is the one who brought the Orange County group together.

Jen moved to Orange County with her family for a fresh start. In the premiere, she says she feels in a “crisis of faith” as her marriage breaks down, and she tells the camera she has hit her breaking point. That is about her marriage and her divorce, not about leaving the church.

Aspyn Ovard

Aspyn Ovard was baptized in the Latter-day Saint church as a child. She is not Mormon now. She has said so publicly, including in a video from May 2026.

Aspyn’s break from the church shows up in the season. In Episode 2, she pressed McCall DaPron and Jordan McClanahan to say they support gay rights, despite the Mormon Church’s practices. Aspyn told Bustle the group talked about politics a lot in that conversation, and that it was cut from the show. She said: “I wasn’t looking for them to just say they support my relationship. I want the people I surround myself with to be aligned with supporting human rights.”

Avery Woods

Avery Woods has said she has “never been a religious person.” She does not identify as Mormon, and she did not come to the show from a Mormon background.

Avery is a former PICU nurse turned full-time creator and the host of the Cheers! podcast. Her faith, or lack of it, is not a storyline in the season. She has simply been clear about it when asked.

McCall DaPron

McCall DaPron is a practicing member of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints. She is Mayci Neeley’s older sister, and she is one of the cast members whose faith is central to how she lives.

McCall helped her best friend Jordan McClanahan convert to Mormonism. She has joked that she has a “McCalling” to bring people to the church. Her faith is not a question mark in the season. It is how she presents herself, as a wife, a mom of four, and a practicing member.

Madison Bontempo

Madison Bontempo practices the faith. She is one of the cast members who practices and wants the show to show it fairly.

Madison is a mom of five and the creator of the FishFam channel with her husband Kyler Fisher. Her marriage, not her faith, is the storyline that drives her season. The questions about her marriage build through the Vegas trip and into the finale.

Salomé Andrea

Salomé Andrea grew up practicing Mormonism. She does not actively practice now.

Salomé is a TikTok creator with over 2 million followers across her channels. She married photographer Aaron Brimhall in 2012, and they share twin daughters Luca and Rue. Her faith background is part of her story, but she has been clear that she does not actively practice the religion now.

Ashleigh Pease

Ashleigh Pease was raised strictly in the Latter-day Saint faith. She married her husband Nathan in the Salt Lake City temple.

Ashleigh is the first Australian-born cast member of the franchise. She is a mom of four and the founder of Get Fit for Kids. Her upbringing in the faith is verified. Earlier reporting said she and Nathan had not publicly shared their religious affiliations, but the Los Angeles Times cast feature from November 12, 2026 identifies her as an active member of the church.

Jordan McClanahan

Jordan McClanahan was raised Lutheran. She converted to Mormonism as an adult, was baptized in 2016 at age 26, and was sealed in the Newport Beach temple.

Jordan is a fitness trainer and a mom of four. Her best friend McCall DaPron helped her convert, and McCall has said she has a “McCalling” to bring people to the church. Jordan joined the cast late, after having a newborn baby, and she was introduced in Episode 3 as McCall’s lifelong best friend.

Bobbi Althoff

Bobbi Althoff is not Mormon. She is the outsider of the group, a comedian and podcaster who joined the cast without a Mormon background.

Bobbi built her name on her deadpan interview style and her podcast, The Really Good Podcast. She is the only cast member who does not come from the faith at all, and that is part of why she stands out in the group. She has said she was terrified about how the footage of her early fights with McCall would be edited and how she would be perceived.

Where to Watch

All 8 episodes of The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives: Orange County stream on Hulu in the US and Disney+ internationally. The full season dropped at once on Nov 12, 2026.

The show is the first spinoff of Hulu’s The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives. It follows a new circle of young mothers in Orange County, in a community where beliefs are their religion and their identity.

Frequently Asked Questions About the Orange County Cast and Mormonism

Are all the Orange County stars Mormon?

No. The cast is a mix. Jen Affleck, McCall DaPron, Madison Bontempo, and Jordan McClanahan are practicing members. Aspyn Ovard and Salomé Andrea were raised in the faith and do not practice now. Ashleigh Pease was raised strictly in the faith and married in the Salt Lake City temple. Avery Woods has said she has never been a religious person. Bobbi Althoff is not Mormon.

Is Bobbi Althoff Mormon?

No. Bobbi Althoff is not Mormon. She is a comedian and podcaster who joined the cast without a Mormon background, and she is the outsider of the group.

Did Jordan McClanahan convert to Mormonism?

Yes. Jordan McClanahan was raised Lutheran. She converted to Mormonism as an adult, was baptized in 2016 at age 26, and was sealed in the Newport Beach temple. Her best friend McCall DaPron helped her convert.

Is Aspyn Ovard still Mormon?

No. Aspyn Ovard was baptized in the Latter-day Saint church as a child, but she is not Mormon now. She has said so publicly, including in a video from May 2026.

Which cast members are practicing Latter-day Saints?

Jen Affleck, McCall DaPron, Madison Bontempo, and Jordan McClanahan are practicing members. Jordan converted as an adult and was baptized in 2016. Ashleigh Pease was raised strictly in the faith and married in the Salt Lake City temple.

Is Madison Bontempo Mormon?

Yes. Madison Bontempo practices the faith. She is one of the cast members who practices and wants the show to show it fairly.

Maya Chen, TV & Film Editor at OpenThreadNews

Written for TV & Film

Maya Chen

Maya has covered television and film for five years, starting as a recapper for a streaming fan site before moving into entertainment journalism. She watches an unreasonable amount of TV across every genre, which makes her the right person to tell you what is actually worth your time. At OpenThreadNews, she leads coverage of reality TV, scripted series, and film, with episode breakdowns, cast features, and industry analysis. Her approach is straightforward: no spoilers without warning, no hype without substance, and always an eye on the craft behind the entertainment.

More from Maya Chen →